Although both home automatic voltage protectors and surge protectors are protective devices in the power system, their functions and working principles are different. What is an automatic voltage protector (AVP)? What is a surge protector? The difference between an automatic voltage protector (AVP) and a surge protector, is when to use a home automatic voltage protector vs. a surge protector, when do you need a home automatic voltage protector? When do you need a surge protector?
What is an Automatic Voltage Protector (AVP)?
Automatic Voltage Protector (AVP) is an electrical device designed to protect electrical equipment and circuits from overvoltage and overcurrent, ensuring the safety and stability of the equipment. It protects the equipment from damage by limiting the overvoltage and overcurrent received by the equipment. The working principle of AVP is based on the discharge of voltage and the blocking of current. When the power is supplied, the current passes through the hardware part of the AVP, such as a gas discharge tube or a varistor.
If there is a current fluctuation or a sudden increase in voltage in the circuit, the AVP can react faster and release a large amount of current instantly to dissipate the energy of the overvoltage and keep the voltage of the circuit stable. In addition, AVP also includes components such as transformers and capacitors to ensure that the voltage and current received by the equipment are within a safe range. When the circuit voltage returns to normal, the protector will automatically return to working state, thus providing reliable protection for electrical equipment
What is a Surge Protection Device(SPD)?
Surge Protection Device (SPD) is an electronic device mainly used to limit transient overvoltage caused by lightning, namely lightning surges, and can also limit most operating surges. Its main function is to limit the surge voltage by discharging the surge current and protect the protected equipment or system from damage caused by the impact.
The role of the surge protector is to limit the instantaneous overvoltage that penetrates the power line and signal transmission line within the voltage range that the equipment or system can withstand or to discharge the strong lightning current into the ground. This device plays an indispensable role in the lightning protection of electronic equipment.
Automatic Voltage Protector (AVP) VS Surge Protection Device
2.1. Design
The design of AVP involves the method of improving the dynamic response speed of the voltage regulation module. By establishing a small signal model of the voltage regulation module, the relationship between the dynamic characteristics and the circuit parameters and control loop, as well as the concepts of critical inductance and critical bandwidth are analyzed in detail to achieve the best compromise between the dynamic performance and efficiency of the voltage regulation module.
The design principle of the surge protection device is mainly based on the work of its internal nonlinear elements, such as varistors, gas discharge tubes, transient suppression diodes, etc., through which these elements quickly turn on when the voltage exceeds its limit value, converting the overvoltage into current and discharging it to the ground, thereby limiting the voltage peak at the device end and protecting subsequent equipment from damage.
2.2. Function
The main function of an automatic voltage protector (AVP) is to regulate and stabilize voltage levels, ensuring that electronic devices receive consistent and safe power. It is often used in areas where power is unreliable or fluctuating, using a combination of transformers and circuits to adjust the incoming voltage to a safe and stable connected device. Voltage protectors are designed to maintain consistent voltage levels and provide a stable power environment for electronic devices. 12.
A surge protector (SPD), also known as a surge protector or lightning arrester, has the main function of limiting instantaneous overvoltage and discharging surge current to protect the protected equipment. The working principle of a surge protector relies on specific components, such as varistors (MOVs), gas discharge tubes (GDTs), and transient suppression diodes (TVSs), which present a high impedance state under normal operating voltage. When the voltage exceeds its threshold, the impedance drops rapidly, forming a conductive channel to absorb and disperse the surge energy, thereby protecting subsequent equipment from damage.
2.3. Working
The working principle of the automatic voltage protector is mainly to protect the connected equipment and system from damage by monitoring the change of voltage and taking corresponding measures when the voltage is too high or too low.
The automatic voltage protector performs buck and boost operations through internal circuits to adjust the input voltage and ensure that the output voltage remains within a certain range. These operations can be performed automatically by manual switches or electronic circuits. When the voltage condition is unfavorable, the boost operation increases the voltage to the rated level, while the buck operation reduces the voltage level during the overvoltage condition. These operations are designed to keep the system voltage stable and prevent equipment damage or system instability caused by voltage fluctuations.
The working principle of the surge protection device mainly relies on its internal nonlinear elements, such as varistors (MOVs), gas discharge tubes (GDTs), or semiconductor devices (such as [TVS diodes), which quickly turn on when the voltage exceeds its limit value, converting the overvoltage into current and discharging it to the ground, thereby limiting the voltage peak at the device end.
2.4. Application
With the popularization of household appliances, automatic voltage protectors provide different voltage protection for residential appliances to ensure the safety of electricity use. The main application scope of home automatic voltage protectors includes protecting various electrical appliances in the home, especially those that require high voltage stability, such as televisions, computers, air conditioners, refrigerators, washing machines, etc. These devices may be damaged when the voltage fluctuates, so the use of home automatic voltage protectors can effectively avoid equipment damage caused by excessively high or low voltages and ensure the safe operation of home appliances.
Surge protectors (SPDs) are widely used in various scenarios, including power systems, communication systems, computer networks, industrial control systems, and homes and offices. The main function of a surge protector is to limit surge voltage by discharging surge current to prevent transient overvoltage caused by lightning or other reasons from damaging sensitive electronic equipment.
When to use a home automatic voltage protector vs. a surge protector
If your family is mainly concerned that voltage fluctuations (too high or too low) may damage electrical appliances, then an automatic voltage protector is a more appropriate choice.
If you are worried that surges caused by lightning or other reasons may damage sensitive electronic equipment, such as televisions, computers, etc., then a surge protector is a more appropriate choice.
In areas prone to lightning or where there is a concern that electrical equipment is vulnerable to lightning damage, it is recommended to install both an automatic voltage protector and a surge protector to provide more comprehensive protection.
4.1 When Do You Need an Automatic Voltage Protector for Home?
In areas with unstable power grid quality: In some areas with unstable power grid quality, voltage often fluctuates, which may be caused by relatively backward regional power infrastructure, excessive load, or weather factors. If the area where the home is located often has excessively high or low voltage, it is very necessary to install an overvoltage and Undervoltage protector. It can effectively monitor and adjust the voltage to ensure the safe operation of household electrical equipment and avoid equipment damage or performance degradation caused by abnormal voltage.
Many and expensive household electrical appliances:
In modern households, there are more and more electrical appliances, such as TVs, computers, audio systems, air conditioners, refrigerators, etc. These devices have high requirements for voltage stability. Once the voltage is abnormal, it may cause equipment damage and high repair and replacement costs. If there are multiple expensive electrical appliances in the home, installing an overvoltage and Undervoltage protector can play an important protective role, ensuring that the equipment operates in a stable voltage environment and extending the service life of the equipment1.
Strong awareness of electricity safety:
As people’s safety awareness continues to improve, more and more people are beginning to pay attention to household electricity safety. Voltage abnormalities will not only affect electrical appliances but may also cause safety accidents such as electrical fires. For home users with a strong sense of electricity safety, installing an over- and under-voltage protector is an effective means of protecting the home power system, which can prevent various safety hazards caused by voltage problems and ensure the personal safety of family members.
Special family members:
If there are elderly, children, or frail members in the family, they have higher requirements for the stability of the living environment. Voltage fluctuations will not only affect the normal use of electrical appliances but may also cause great inconvenience to the lives of these special members. To ensure the comfort and safety of special family members, it is particularly important to install over- and under-voltage protectors.
Important electronic devices at home:
For some families engaged in remote office, online education, or relying on electronic devices for work, voltage stability is even more important. Voltage fluctuations may cause computers, servers, or other office equipment to suddenly lose power, resulting in data loss or equipment damage, which in turn affects work and study efficiency. Installing an overvoltage and Undervoltage protector can provide a stable power supply for these key devices and avoid the negative impact of abnormal voltage on work and study.
In summary, whether it is necessary to install an overvoltage and Undervoltage protector in a family depends on many factors, including the quality of the power grid, the situation of household electrical appliances, safety awareness, and the special needs of family members.
4.2 When Do You Need a Surge Protection Device?
The situations in which surge protection devices are needed mainly include the following:
Lightning protection: Lightning is one of the main sources of surges, which can directly or indirectly invade electronic equipment through power lines or signal lines and cause damage. Even with protective measures such as lightning rods, down conductors, and grounding devices, it is difficult to completely prevent lightning induction and surge intrusion along the line, so surge protection devices are needed to provide additional protection.
Operation surge: The start, stop, and switching operations of electrical equipment may cause voltage spikes, which can also damage the equipment. Surge protection devices can limit these instantaneous overvoltages and protect the protected equipment.
Electrostatic discharge: Electrostatic discharge of electronic equipment can also generate instantaneous overvoltage, causing damage to the equipment. Surge protection devices can absorb and clamp these overvoltages to protect the equipment from damage.
Protection of high-value equipment: For information electronic equipment and/or power electronic equipment with higher value and greater impact in buildings, their ability to withstand lightning surges is much lower than that of conventional electrical equipment. These devices are more sensitive to surges, so surge protection devices are needed to provide additional protection1.
Inside and outside the system surge: The surge outside the system mainly comes from outside the system, with a high instantaneous peak value, while the surge inside the system is oscillatory. Both types of surges can cause damage to the equipment. Surge protection devices use threshold suppression network technology to effectively protect electrical equipment from high-energy pulse surges.
In summary, surge protection devices are suitable for various occasions that need to prevent lightning, operating surges, and electrostatic discharge damage, especially for the protection of high-value electronic equipment.
Conclusion
Although both automatic voltage protectors and surge protectors are designed to protect electronic equipment from power problems, their designs, working principles, and protection targets are different. Voltage protectors focus on maintaining a stable voltage output, while surge protectors focus on preventing voltage spikes and surges from damaging your equipment.
English 
Español