A Surge Arrester and a Voltage Surge Protector are both devices designed to protect electrical systems and equipment from voltage spikes or surges, but they serve slightly different roles and have different applications. Here’s a comparison between the two:
Surge Arrester
Purpose: Surge arresters (often referred to as lightning arresters) are primarily used to protect electrical systems from high-energy surges, such as those caused by lightning strikes or switching operations in power lines.
How It Works: Surge arresters divert the surge energy safely to the ground. They have a non-linear resistance that becomes very low during a surge, providing a path for the excess voltage to flow to the ground, preventing the surge from reaching sensitive equipment.
Location: Typically installed on high-voltage power lines, electrical substations, or around transformers. Surge arresters are mostly used in industrial and utility applications, rather than for protecting household electronics.
Design: Surge arresters are usually built with varistor materials, such as zinc oxide (ZnO), and are designed to handle large amounts of energy from high-voltage surges.
Energy Handling: Surge arresters are designed to absorb and dissipate large amounts of energy and protect the electrical infrastructure.
Voltage Surge Protector
These surges can occur due to various reasons, such as lightning strikes, power line fluctuations, or electrical switching. The surge protector ensures that any sudden increase in voltage doesn’t reach the device you’re trying to protect, like a computer, television, or home appliance.
Purpose: Voltage surge protector (also known as a surge protector or surge suppressor) is designed to protect low-voltage household or office electronics from voltage spikes or transients that can be caused by lightning, switching, or other electrical disturbances.
How It Works:Automatic Voltage Protector (AVP), also known as an Automatic Voltage Regulator (AVR) or Voltage Stabilizer, is designed to protect electrical appliances from voltage fluctuations by automatically adjusting the input voltage to a safe and stable level. The AVP is particularly useful in regions where the power supply is inconsistent, with frequent voltage dips, surges, or overvoltages.
Location: Surge protectors are typically used in households, such as protecting computers, home appliances, TVs, and other sensitive electronics.
Design: Voltage surge protectors are often built into power strips or dedicated units, and they usually include features like LED indicators to show if the device is still functioning properly.
Energy Handling: Surge protectors are designed to handle smaller amounts of energy than surge arresters. They protect individual devices or circuits rather than entire power systems.
Surge Arrester VS Voltage Surge Protector
| Feature | Surge Arrester | Voltage Surge Protector |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Protects electrical infrastructure (high voltage) | Protects individual low-voltage electronics |
| Application | High-voltage power lines, substations | Home/office appliances, sensitive electronics |
| Energy Handling | Handles large energy surges, such as from lightning | Handles smaller surges or transients |
| Common Components | Zinc oxide varistor, gas discharge tubes | Metal oxide varistor (MOV), gas discharge tubes |
| Location | Power stations, transformers, high-voltage networks | Power strips, surge protection outlets |
| Voltage Rating | High voltage (up to hundreds of kilovolts) | Low voltage (typically 120V or 240V) |
Voltage Surge Protector Function
Voltage Monitoring:
The AVP continuously monitors the incoming voltage from the power supply. It has sensors or circuits that track whether the voltage is within the specified safe range for the connected appliances (e.g., 220V ± 10% in most regions).
Voltage Fluctuations Detection:
When the incoming voltage deviates from the safe range (either too high or too low), the AVP detects the fluctuation. Voltage dips (brownouts), surges (spikes), or overvoltages can all cause damage to sensitive electronic devices if not corrected promptly.
Automatic Disconnection:
If the voltage exceeds the protection limits (for example, if the voltage is too high for a prolonged period), the AVP will disconnect the load (appliance) from the power supply to protect it. Once the voltage returns to normal levels, the AVP reconnects the device automatically.
Delay Mechanism:
Many AVPs have a time-delay feature to prevent short cycling, where the device automatically waits for a brief period (usually a few seconds or minutes) after detecting a voltage fluctuation before reconnecting the appliances. This delay allows the power supply to stabilize and avoids damage from frequent switching on and off.
summary
Surge arresters are primarily used in high-voltage systems to protect infrastructure from large energy surges like those caused by lightning strikes.
Voltage surge protectors are typically used for lower-voltage devices, like computers and home appliances, to shield them from transient surges and voltage spikes.
In essence, both devices protect against surges, but the scale of the protection they offer and the environments in which they are used differ significantly.
Surge arresters are for larger-scale infrastructure protection, while surge protectors are for protecting household or office electronics.
English 
Español